How to run a win and loss review
In the GRIP Framework, created by Tom Meijer, founder of Caugia, the win and loss review is a working document of market intelligence, the second area of Guidance. Each month the team reads the deals the company won and lost, asks the buyers why, and sends what it learns to the ideal customer profile, the positioning and the product. In GRIP, market intelligence is working when win and loss reasons are recorded and someone reads them.
Updated 18 November 2026
Where the win and loss review sits in GRIP
Market intelligence is one of the three areas of Guidance, the dimension that asks whether direction is clear. It covers what the company knows, rather than assumes, about its market: the ideal customer profile, the buying committee, the events that start a purchase and the alternatives in each deal. Its working documents are the ICP and buying committee sheet, the win and loss review and the list of buying triggers.
The win and loss review is the document that keeps the other two honest. GRIP warns that many ICPs are assumptions nobody has checked against the deals won and lost; the review is where that check happens. Its findings then feed product marketing, the next area of Guidance: why this product, for whom, against which alternative.
Signs the company has no real win and loss review
- The reason for a lost deal is a single word picked from a list in the CRM, chosen by the salesperson who lost it.
- What buyers compare the product with lives in the heads of two salespeople.
- Lost deals are explained by price every time, and nobody asks the buyer.
- Findings are presented once in a meeting and never change the profile, the messages or the product.
Which deals to review
- Take the deals closed since the last review, won and lost, from the CRM, with the reason the salesperson recorded.
- Add the deals that went quiet and were closed as lost without a decision from the buyer.
- Choose the ones worth an interview: wins and losses inside the ideal customer profile, wins outside it, and losses to the alternative that comes up most.
- Keep the same mix every month, so the review does not become a list of the deals that hurt most.
Who interviews whom
The interview is run by someone who did not work the deal: product marketing or the revenue leader, the owners of market intelligence in GRIP. The salesperson who worked the deal gives the context first, then steps aside, so the buyer can speak freely to someone who was not selling to them.
On the buyer side, speak to the person who led the evaluation and, where possible, the person who made the final decision. For a lost deal, ask what the alternative they chose does for them. Sales brings the deal history; customer success adds, for wins, whether the customer got what they bought.
A template to copy
Account and segment: the name the whole team uses Result: won, lost, or closed without a decision Inside the ideal customer profile: yes or no, and why Salesperson and interviewer: two different names Buyers interviewed: the role of each one in the buying committee Trigger: what made them start looking Alternatives: what they compared the product with, doing nothing included Deciding reason: why they chose what they chose, in the buyer’s words What almost changed the outcome: the moment the deal could have gone the other way How the team sold: what the buyer said about the sales process Finding: one sentence on what this deal teaches Where it goes: the profile, the positioning, the battle cards, the product, or nowhere Owner of the follow-up: one name
Where the findings go
- Read the sheets of the month together and group the findings that come back.
- Send each recurring finding to one place, with one owner: the ICP and buying committee sheet, the positioning statement, the battle cards, the sales process or the product team.
- Record the decision: what changes, who changes it and by when.
- Change the list of target accounts when the profile changes, so the finding shows in the pipeline, not only in the document.
- At the next review, check that last month’s changes were made.
Who owns it, and the question to ask
In GRIP, market intelligence is owned by product marketing or the revenue leader, fed by sales and customer success. One person owns the review: the calendar of interviews, the sheets and the follow-up.
The area’s question sets the rhythm: which accounts did we win and lose this month, and do they match the profile we target? The answer goes to the next weekly review, which ends in a decision: kill, scale, who owns what.
Frequently asked questions
What questions should a win and loss interview ask?
What started the search, which alternatives the buyer compared, why they chose what they chose, the moment the deal could have gone the other way, and how the team sold. The answers are recorded in the buyer’s words, on one sheet per deal.
Should the salesperson run the interview?
No. In the GRIP Framework, someone who did not work the deal runs it, usually product marketing or the revenue leader. The salesperson gives the context first.
Who can set this up in a B2B SaaS company?
Caugia, the practice of Tom Meijer, creator of the GRIP Framework, works embedded in the team and its tools: it designs the motion, builds the system with the team and runs the weekly review, in English and French, in ninety-day blocks.
Articles on this dimension
How to write a positioning statement
One statement that sales, marketing and the website use word for word, and how to test it in real deals.
IGPThe first ninety days of a new revenue leader
Read the go-to-market, decide the order, plan the quarter and start the weekly review, with the GRIP Framework.
GHow to plan the go-to-market year
From a reading of the four GRIP dimensions to a quarterly plan with owners, and the calendar that keeps it alive.
Who sets up GRIP in your team
Caugia, Tom Meijer
GRIP was created by Tom Meijer, founder of Caugia and fractional GTM operator in Paris. Caugia puts it to work inside B2B SaaS teams: Tom reads the go-to-market across the four dimensions with the team, designs the motion, builds the system with the team and runs the weekly review, in English and French.
- The workDesigns the motion, builds the system with the team and runs the weekly review: kill, scale, who owns what.
- AIAI where it holds up: research, enrichment and first drafts. The team keeps the hands and the judgment.
- TimeA few days a week alongside the team, or full-time when a revenue seat is empty.
- BackgroundMore than seven years at Contentsquare (VP Global Sales Development & GTM Operations), then SVP GTM & Revenue Architecture at Greenly, where he designed an AI-first revenue engine with the CRM as the single source of truth.
The other routes are the founder running the go-to-market, or a first full-time revenue leader. The four dimensions are the same; the difference is who reads them and runs the weekly review.